Exploring the Timeless Satire of Charlie Chaplin’s "The Great Dictator" in a World of Modern Tyrants
Story by Noah Smith
04/28/24
In the annals of cinematic history, few films have dared to tackle the subject of dictators and the havoc they wreak with the audacity and incisive wit of Charlie Chaplin’s “The Great Dictator.” Released in 1940, this audacious satire took direct aim at Adolf Hitler, an act of artistic defiance that came at a time when the United States was still at peace with Nazi Germany.
Chaplin, the silent film icon who had captivated audiences as the Little Tramp, stepped into the era of sound films with a feature that was both a stark condemnation of fascism and a masterful display of comedy. He played dual roles as the Jewish barber, a figure harkening back to his beloved Tramp, and Adenoid Hynkel, the film’s blustering Hitler-like despot.
The film emerged amid considerable trepidation from Hollywood studios, which, up until that point, had largely avoided overt criticism of Hitler due to financial entanglements with the German film market and fear of isolationist backlash in the U.S. Even United Artists, which Chaplin co-founded, was concerned about the film’s potential to offend and the impact it might have on international relations. Yet, fueled by a blend of personal conviction and creative independence, Chaplin pressed on, self-financing much of the production.
Chaplin’s satire did not pull punches. It featured Hynkel delivering nonsensical tirades in a mock-German gibberish, humorously capturing the furor of Hitler’s oratory style. The film’s humor was not just surface-level slapstick; it was layered with a poignant examination of what made such figures both compelling and terrifying.
The film’s climax came not from a comedic routine but from a sincere monologue that Chaplin, breaking character, delivered directly to the audience. Speaking not as Hynkel but as the barber, he made a plea for universal brotherhood, compassion, and democracy, a monologue that resonated with its call for U.S. intervention in Europe at a time when the horrors of war were escalating.
Despite the challenges and resistance faced during its production, “The Great Dictator” became one of Chaplin’s most commercially successful films. It was a critical triumph that earned nominations for five Academy Awards, including Outstanding Production and Best Actor for Chaplin himself. It also stood out as an emblem of Hollywood’s potential to tackle pressing social and political issues without succumbing to external pressures, a testament to the power of art to defy tyranny.
There's more than one way to solve a case in the new series. Try Paramount+ free!
Paramount+
There's more than one way to solve a case in the new series. Try Paramount+ free!
Ad
Relevant articles:
– TIL In 1940, Charlie Chaplin produced and financed the film ‘The Great Dictator’, which mocked Hitler. Hollywood studios were hesitant to produce the film due to their financial relations with Germany. ‘The Great Dictator’ is considered one of Chaplin’s greatest works.
– The Great Dictator, Wikipedia
– The Great Dictator, Wikipedia
– What Charlie Chaplin Got Right About Satirizing Hitler, Vanity Fair, Oct 18, 2019